War Stories

Written by Cheryl Cain
Directed by James Contner

Synopsis | Perri's Review | SunSpeak

Synopsis

Simon sort of listens to Book lecturing about a psychotic Chinese warrior poet who specialized in torture to find out what people 'really are', as he studies River's brain scans. Simon dismisses Book's theory that the government experimented on River just to see how far they could go, but Simon points out that they had to be doing something specific -- or they wouldn't still be after her. Simon's still trying different medications to fix the damage, and she's doing slightly better, but not fixed. On a nearby space station, our old buddy Niska is in the middle of following the lessons of Shan Yu to punish a traitor, and has moved on to finding his 'true self', when he is notified that a Firefly that could be Serenity is on the other side of the world. Niska looks... happy.

Inara explains to Mal that a high-ranking client will be coming on-board, and wants total privacy and peace. But Mal is dead-set on meeting anyone who comes aboard ship, and the peace is currently being disturbed by a ship-wide game of keep-away between Kaylee and River. Kaylee regains possession of her apple (courtesy of Jayne, who bought a crate with his cut of the medical haul) in the common room; after some chit-chat and a war story, Mal appears to tell everyone they're about to make their last drop; at the same time, he tells Wash that going straight to the local MDs wasn't a bad idea, but it's not workable. That leads to a major marital spat as Serenity lands, Wash accusing Zoe of not standing up for him with the captain, then lying to Wash about not being able to bring the idea up at all. Comments regarding Zoe's inability to do anything the Captain doesn't tell her to make things worse, as Zoe says she disagreed with the plan too, and Wash tells her to tell him next time instead of letting the Captain do her dirty work. Wash storms out. Simon finds River sick in their quarters, a side-effect of the drug. Short-term improvement only, and River's not having an easy time of it. The entire crew turns out to eavesdrop as Inara's client arrives; their jaws drop collectively with the Councilor is a gorgeous woman whom Inara leads into her shuttle. As Mal and Zoe head out for the drop-off, they can't fly the shuttle -- Wash has decided he wants to go on this run instead of his wife, and isn't taking no for an answer. He gets his way when Zoe gives in, but Mal ain't happy. He's even less happy when the drop-off turns into a professional ambush; the buyers are killed, and Mal and Wash taken prisoner.

Following a fairly pointless interlude [which proves how much Joss and Company miss Tara and Willow], the Councilor leaves again; Zoe appears to grab Jayne since the Captain and Wash are an hour overdue; Book tags along. They quickly find the ambush point, and the signs of a rocket shuttle; all evidence points to the space station, and Zoe knows what that means. Mal and Wash are shoved into a room, blindfolded and tied, and pass the time by kicking the Zoe-fight into high gear -- until Niska decides to come collect his toys. Aboard Serenity, Zoe collects what's left of everyone's cuts, ready to go offer it in exchange for the guys, and heads off to the rescue, but Niska has already started with the torture potion of the evening. Mal keeps the Zoe fight going even in the middle of electro-shock anti-therapy, trying to keep Wash mad enough not to break (including a long interlude over whether Mal has slept with Zoe, and how he's going to the second they get back to Serenity). He succeeds; Zoe arrives with money in hand, but Niska's bastard enough to only give her one guy for that price. She chooses Wash without hesitation.

Zoe gets Wash back to Serenity, leaving Mal behind for new and more inventive forms of torture -- including Niska cutting his ear off as a 'rebate' for Zoe's cash. Zoe hands it over to Simon for later reattachment, and she and Wash get down to some serious planning; Wash knows what Mal did for him, and is determined to go back. As Niska tries out a horrid new machine on Mal (in Mal), the rest of the crew register their belief that Zoe and Wash are crazy -- then the entire bunch (sans Inara, trying to get political help planetside) arms themselves to go along to help. But they may be too late, as Niska's henchman pronounced Mal dead.

Turns out he's only mostly dead, and Niska resuscitates him for more fun. He has a reputation to uphold, after all. Serenity coasts in dead under Wash's expert hands; it buys them the element of surprise when they dock, break through the airlock doors, and come out shooting. Alarms blare, things start exploding, and people start dying -- fortunately, all of them are on the other side. Simon, Book and Kaylee are left to hold the ship as the other three invade. Distracted by the noises outside, neither niska nor his henchman see Mal breaking free, until he puts the nasty little machine on the henchman's back. He falls, and Niska faces a truly pissed-off Malcolm Reynolds. Jayne takes a hit in the corridors, and Zoe goes Matrix and clears the way. Book and Simon get called forward to offer cover, leaving a terrified Kaylee to guard the ship. When three men converge, she runs back into the ship, unable to fight. It's River who comes up beside her, assesses the situation, and fires three shots with her eyes closed, dropping all three men in a second. Mal beats the crap out of Niska, but his henchman recovers; the ensuing brawl takes them over a long, wide transport/air shaft. As they wrestle, the cavalry charges in -- at a word from Mal, they empty their weapons into the henchman, who falls over the edge, extremely dead.

Back on Serenity Simon has reattached Mal's ear using equipment on loan from the councilor. Simon's recovering from battle, but Kaylee's still freaked by what River did, though she doesn't seem to have told anyone. Zoe cooks a meal for Wash, but as he's enjoying it, Mal comes in to claim what he told Wash he was going to do -- sleep with Zoe as soon as they got back on ship. Zoe plays along with a ridiculous lack of chemistry until Wash has enough, and drags her off to their bunk, all issues settled, or about to be.

Perri's Review

Now that was a solid hour of action, although I could have done without the torture scenes. < shudder > But any episode with Wash and Zoe at the center can't be anything but cool.

Continuity:
Bad-guy Niska from
The Train Job returned to wreak revenge, but seems to be in the custody of the authorities now.

Relationships:
Wash and Zoe had that knock-down, drag-out fight some of us have been expecting, and seem to be the better for it.

Characters:
Finally, Wash and Zoe get their turn in the spotlight -- and for Wash, it's by displaying his heretofore nearly ignored testosterone. < snicker > Seriously, I have been expecting an explosion re: Mal and Zoe for quite some time -- the two of them act like an old married couple, which tends to be unavoidable in soldiers who've worked together for that long -- which doesn't make it any less grating to the other half of the actual married couple. So, Wash finally got pushed over the edge and became obnoxious about it. I'll give him points -- Zoe did screw up by using Mal to shoot down Wash's idea; that was completely not fair. But the whole sabotaging the shuttle to go on the run thing? Childish. I can see why he did it, wanting to prove the "anything she can do, I can do, too" thing -- except that he can't. He's good at entirely different things than Mal and Zoe, and hopefully getting them aboard the space station will be enough to remind him of that periodically. In addition to his new knowledge of how much firefights actually do suck.

Zoe, for her part, has to walk a fairly fine line some days -- she's her husband's superior, which can put any guy's hackles up, and she has to be tough chick to do her job. And reading the captain's mind is definitely part of her duties as XO, which is also not designed to endear her to her husband. So she has to balance her duties as XO with being an equal partner in a marriage, and occasionally, she's going to screw up. It takes someone was laid-back and unthreatened as Wash is (usually) to deal with the whole situation, and I think his good nature is something she started taking for granted, or she never would have done something as dumb as shooting him down through Mal. Lesson learned. And, for the record, she made exactly the right choice taking Wash out. Mal survived -- Wash probably wouldn't have. Niska sucks, but Zoe rocks.

And Mal continues to demonstrate why he's the captain. He tolerates rampaging girls and marital disputes with surprising patience (for Mal), keeps Wash going throughout the torture, and agrees with Zoe's choice to get Wash out without, it seems, even one little second thought. And then turns around and gleefully tortures Wash once it's all over. The scene with him and Zoe is utterly classic, as much from the silliness as from the almost total lack of chemistry between them. (Which took some acting on Nathan Fillion's part, since Gina Torres, I am convinced, would have chemistry with a rock.) If you weren't in love with Mal before this episode, you have no excuse for not being so after it.

I'm not surprised and actually a bit pleased that Kaylee's nerve failed in the firefight. Not pleased for Kaylee's character, since I like my chicks of the tough variety, but she's a mechanic, and damned young. It's a hell of a lot more convincing that she would freak than that she'd be able to race out guns a-blazing, which is good for the believability of the show all around. It was, actually, quite cool. Less cool is that she's also, apparently, freaked by River now; again, it's hard to blame her, since watching a younger girl kill three people in a second is nothing to blow off. And she's maybe also a little ashamed that River could do what she couldn't... But the two of them playing was so much fun.

My current theory about Book is that he's ex-Special Forces or the Alliance equivalent (my dad's theory is current Special Forces undercover; we'll see who's right). A spritual crisis of some kind sends him into retirement, and off looking for God...? It would explain a lot about his knowledge of weapons and his aim, wouldn't it? Book just keeps getting cooler and cooler, when I'd early on pegged him as one of the more potentially boring characters. Just goes to show how much you can't tell from publicity materials and pilots.

Cool -- Inara does have female clients. The group reaction was funny as hell (particularly Jayne), even if the sex was gratuitous, and I note that Inara was the one freaking out most about Mal's absence when Zoe and Wash came back. Color me so surprised. Simon maintains his usual coolness throughout -- caught between the Hippocratic oath and an actual life of someone he owes, he sucked it up and fought. Although I wonder how much of his horrific aim was subconsciously trying to avoid breaking the oath.... Anyway. He and River continue to be adorable together. And Jayne was cool, going with them after Mal and, apparently, trying to expiate some guilt through apple bribery. There may be hope for him yet.

Niska is mean, bad and evil. I wish Mal had killed him, too. But I also like the concept of him in some nice, clean, sterile Alliance cell for the rest of his scrawny little life. Yeah. I can live with that.

Best Moments:
Kaylee and River chasing each other around the ship. They're cute in and of themselves, and made moreso by Mal's "irritated big brother" yelling.

Wash trying to make the apple story happier and cheerier. Way to protect the kids, babe.

Wash and Zoe's fight. Painful, mostly because of how real it felt.

The Councilor's entrance. I watch The West Wing, I knew Sunglasses Guy was Secret Service. < snicker > And all of the dropped jaws were too funny.

"I threw up on your bed." < g > I am just never going to get tired of River and Simon.

Jayne's fascination with the two women. He is such a guy. A strong guy -- he hefted that weight one-handed, Geez.

Wash and Zoe loading up for war. Very cute married couple stuff interspersed with the dead-serious invasion stuff.

"It is, however, somewhat fuzzier on the subject of kneecaps." Book. Just. Rocks.

The entire invasion sequence. A very cool firefight, with great bits for everyone.

River Oakley. Very cool, adding yet another layer of wierdness to the girl that someone really should be commenting on by now...

"This is something the captain has to do for himself." Only, not. < snicker > Way to turn those cliches on their ears, oh yeah.

Mal checking on everyone as he wanders through at the end. Making sure Simon's okay, the handclasp with Kaylee, then off to torture Wash....

The entire 'seduction scene'. < giggling >

Questions and Comments:
Nice parallels of WWI and WWII in the trench seige story, although I'm glad they didn't have minigrenades then. < shudder >

The Councilor storyline was largely pointless, except for the help with the medical equipment at the end, but, according to Joss, a pointy scene was cut:

Hey guys. The lesbian scene does come off as gratuitious to some, I get that. The fact is, there was another scene with the councillor where Inara visited her, asking for help and we discovered she had a devoted husband and son. Inara had a chance to use her knowledge of the coucillor's secret against her and didn't use it, prompting the councillor to follow her out, wanting to help, and mistaking Mal for Inara's lover. The scene didn't quite work and the show was quite long, so out it came. So there was further character development intended. Plus, I did want to establish the idea that Inara took clients not based on sexuality, and Jayne's refrain cracks me up to the ends of the earth. So there you have it. Also, I'm pandering.
Although I still think Joss just misses Tara and Willow... [Thanks to Celli for passing the post on]

Odd act breaking in the episode -- act two went on forever, while act three was 5 minutes long. It didn't hurt the pacing much, it was just weird. And maybe only noticeable if you're synopsizing.

Rating:
4 stars out of 5. Tight, action-packed, and with some attention finally given to two badly neglected characters. Very cool stuff.

SunSpeak

"Okay, either Cheryl Cain (writer of tonight's episode) needs to be protected as a newly found natural resource and locked in a room and made to write constantly... or Joss largely rewrote tonight's episode. Sadly, I'm going with "B"." -- Lizbet

"All I can say is I *desperately* need to learn all those Chinese exclamations, 'cause I really found myself wanting to use 'em tonight! And is it an accident that that the *characters* were spouting off such unusually long strings of exasperated Chinese? I so don't think so..."
"I actually *was* trying to swear in Chinese - ask Perri. I have now officially watched this show enough if I'm trying to swear in the correct idiom." -- Valerie and Chris

"Dude! They wussed out on the girly kiss! *pout* "
"*puzzled blink* They did? I mean, okay, not mad and passionate, but definitely there."
"It was neat. Heh. Unexpected, and neat; I liked that women are Inara's way to 'relax.'"
"They had a funky angle on it, so you could hear all the kissy noises but not see it so well. Inara's hair was in the way. (Yes, I looked. Inara's cute, man.) I was deeply irritated by the offended posters on the message board. (Which is why I usually don't go near message boards.) I was all, people, she's a space HOOKER. Your sense of propriety is outraged 'cause some of her johns are jills? Riiiiight." -- Celli, Val, Chris, Celli

"I thought they were wussing out on the [kiss] in Inara's shuttle, and then they panned around. Although I have to say I wish that Inara hadn't made that comment about "a woman has to be *very* special." Unless she was flattering her client a bit. But I would think that Inara, of all people, wouldn't really care which gonads were there."
"I don't think she does in that sense, although it could be just an indication of where she falls naturally on the continuum. In which case, kudos to them for acknowledging that even bi isn't necessarily just 50/50. Judging by the rest of the speech, tho, I wonder if she isn't inclined to develop a stronger emotional bond with female clients than she can professionally afford to." -- Lizbet and Val

"Mal's "huh" made me laugh and laugh, though."
"Oh, God/dess, yes. And Jayne's "I'll be in my bunk." *snickersnerklesnork* Jack's comment: "He has to go do a spell." *snerk*" -- Celli and Val

"One of the things I loved most about [Kaylee's] "origin" flashback in "Out of Gas" was the demonstration that -- in perfectly Kaylee-ish defiance of the TV tomboy stereotype that people might take her for at a glance, not to mention the schoolgirl crush on Simon -- she is a gleefully and healthily sexual being. We first met her unselfconsciously peppering Inara with questions about her work, and she's continued to be as frank and open with her curiosity in that regard as she is about everything else. I'd absolutely love to meet her family -- they must absolutely rock. The girl seems completely and utterly free of neuroses or anxieties about anything other than her ability to fit into unfamiliar situations (which, as we saw in "Shindig", lasted about forty-five seconds)." -- Val

"Wash and Zoe arguing hurt. I mean, I'm glad they're airing their issues, but I didn't realized how attached I was to the two of them til that fight." -- Celli

"Loved Wash, even when I wanted to smack him. Legitimate issues that he and Zoe weren't dealing with as well as they could be, maybe because of close quarters, maybe because it wasn't so obvious before. Zoe's choice was both the one she wanted to make, and the smart one; if they were going to get Mal back, she needed the best pilot, and that was her husband. But I don't for a moment think it was easy. Nishka cutting off Mal's ear just really, reeeeally pissed her off enough to do things right."
"Oh, yeah. Although, for all the apparently cold-blooded control of the "gesture", it was *so* petty, and exposed just how much she'd gotten his goat by depriving him of the agonizing he expected her to do over which of the guys to take. Which was just *so* damn beautiful. Her no-nonsense, no-patience-with-mindgames attitude could not have been more perfect for the situation. Note to pretty much everyone, everywhere: do *not* attempt to bullshit this woman. Ever. Ever ever. Daaaaamn." -- Chris and Val

"Who's this guy they're quoting, the evil Sun Tzu?"
"Sort of. More like the Chinese Machiavelli. I should know what he wrote -- damn near as famous as The Art of War -- but I'm blanking. Pretty sure Disney based Xian Yu in Mulan on him, or a relative. Possibly also Yu Dynasty as in Yu the Great, as in the Goa'uld System Lord. Which would explain a lot." -- Celli and Val

"Inara's not going? Inara could kick some ass. Give her a sword."
"Um, yeah. And watch her get shot by scary people way out of reach to use it on. *grimace* Not that I don't think she can probably handle a gun quite respectably too, but once again her social advantages were needed more. That said, thank all the gods Book's past is becoming more evidently colorful by the day, because there would have been a lot more holes in a couple more members of the crew otherwise. Some very precise shots that were *so* not kneecaps. Not that I expect anyone to call him on it..." -- Celli and Val

"Ooh, Simon with a gun. TV boyfriend! Although Wash can be my platonic TV boyfriend. Dude, he recognized what Mal was doing with the "bed your wife" bit. *hugs Wash*" -- Celli

"Did love how they handled Simon's Hippocratic oath; both because he hasn't broken it, and because they can save him having to do something like that for much later, in more personal circumstances."
"Er... I thought I saw Simon actually connect with some people, and I thought Book was trying to ease it for him. If I'm wrong, then yes. He's already been put in a situation where he was willing to violate his principles; let's turn the screw later when it means something."
"Gotta agree there, although I think they made the firefight deliberately chaotic and confusing to make that not entirely certain. Let's just say I wouldn't swear to it in court." -- Chris, Lizbet and Val

"Kaylee! River! Adorable!"
"Did that not rock in the mightiest? "The pitter-patter of tiny little feet in great big combat boots." I about died. And oh, the *ow* when River freaked Kaylee with the guns... "
"I adore Mal, some days. And yes... major wincing when River saved Kaylee, and Kaylee was too ashamed/freaked to react well, after. Although "No power in the 'verse can stop me" had me laughing. She's morbid and creepifying, but she's *trying* so hard to be normal... pobre River."
"Exactly. Although poor Kaylee was a bit too traumatized to find it funny, and ended up just being more freaked by it. The opening scene gave us a glimpse of something that should have been patently obvious if I'd thought about it: for all that their upbringings were at opposite ends of the social scale, they should *so* be the two people with the most in common on this tub. If and when River ever becomes truly herself again, the others may find themselves almost wishing for the nutcase back once they have a *pair* of barely-post-adolescent girl geniuses frolicking underfoot..." -- Celli, Val, Chris, Val

"*meeeeep* I don't blame [Kaylee] a bit, she was trying so hard, she just froze and freaked, and then to have River come up and not even look -- it *was* freaky. And I bet she's too ashamed/worried about River/freaked to tell anyone about it. I feel worse for River. Proud of her, but sorry that she and Kaylee's friendship took a knock because of the circumstances."
""Can't talk. Can't look." *bang* *bang* *bang* And if and when she's able to think coherently about it, it means that Kaylee now has a piece of the more-than-just-crazy puzzle that nobody else on Serenity does. Should be interesting to see if that goes anywhere." -- Chris and Val

"And now we *really* know what kind of guy Mal is - someone not to turn your back on, even if (or *especially* if) you've been torturing him for hours!"
"Oh, yeah. And [insert Chinese interjections here...the brain is trying to supply something like "ee chai dong kwai", which somewhat frightens me], the look on his face!!!!!! Sure the just-back-from-the-dead makeup helped, but you don't make up the eyes. Brrrrrrrrrrrrrrr." -- Chris and Val

"Between ["The captain has to do this himself."] and the Villian's Emotionally Wrenching Choice Scene < tm > with Zoe, they did a great job of using all the worst cliches and blowing them inside out. :) " -- Dianne

"Man, I love this show. Please let it get renewed, please let it get renewed..."
"Your mouth to Rupert Murdock's ear..." -- Chris and Lizbet